Long Range Interactions beyond first neighbour Intermolecular
Transcrição
Long Range Interactions beyond first neighbour Intermolecular
The four cardinal interactions ( LRI ) Long Range Interactions beyond first neighbour Dispersion plus electrostatic ( steric and entropy) Intermolecular forces organizing complex fluids …Laboratory experiments for challenging predictive theories. >> « standard » PoissonBoltzmann-Lifshitz • Example 1: an hexapeptide as a vdW fluid • Example 2 : a reverse micelle as a vdW fluid [email protected] 1 The van der Waals EOS • Hydration force: V. A. Parsegian and S. Marcelja ( 1974-1977) 2 • Depletion mechanism : S Asakura and F Oosawa (1954) EOS of a van der Waals fluid Equilibrium between a dilute and a dense phase at same (P,T) U sph (r) = − • Measure of concentration gap between phases in equilibrium : givesluation of the strength of the interaction 3 Vg/Vl is relative concentration measures A : attraction Ar 6d 2. N-merisation in solution and octanol/water partitioning a. Solutions in pure solvents. Peptide (1) is well soluble both in water and octanol up to 20 mM (1.3% v/v) at 20 1C. Above this critical concentration a phase separation occurs, leading to the formation of a gel-like solid and a homogeneous liquid phase. Solutions of (1) in water or in octanol have been investigated by means of light scattering. In water, dynamic light scattering (DLS) produced a weak signal leading to an apparent hydrodynamic diameter of about 1.5 nm. This already indicated that the solution does not contain micelles or larger colloidal aggregates. Moreover, molecular weight determination by static light scattering (SLS) via the Debye method gave an apparent molecular weight of 0.6 kDa, confirming that the peptide solution in water is mainly made of monomers, for concentrations below 20 mM. In pure octanol, DLS gave similar results whereas the apparent molecular weight determined by SLS was found to be 2 kDa, corresponding to dimers or trimers. We conclude that this peptide does not self-assemble into micellar- or vesicular-like structures contrary to what observed by other authors on similar peptidic sequences.30–36 Aggregation in large assemblies is not present in octanol: thus, we can consider monomers and dimers as interacting globular colloids, since H-bonds between solvent and peptide backbone are negligible even in the case of octanol.37 Moreover, peptide self-association has already been evidenced in other organic solvents like carbon tetrachloride where polar interactions between peptide and solvent are weaker compared to those observed in water.38 Coacervate as the simlest liquid-gas transition The water-octanol « buyancy » effect The hexapeptide chosen : Ac-Phe-Leu-Val-Pro-Ala-Ala Dimers in water and in octanol 1000 304 nm 800 Intensity (a.u.) 400 200 « globules » plus Dilute solution coacervate b. Partitioning between water and octanol. Peptide (1) was then subjected to partitioning between equal volumes of water octanol 0 250 275 300 325 350 375 400 Emission wavelength (nm) 73075 1uM dans H2O sat en C8OH # 1 RT: 0.02 T: FTMS + p NSI Full ms [650.00-2000.00] 659.3757 100 AV: 1 water NL: 3.31E5 95 90 659.3757 85 [M+H] + 80 75 70 676.4026 65 60 55 50 45 40 676.4026 [M+NH 4]+ [M+M+NH 4]+ 35 1334.7714 30 25 1334.7714 20 15 10 c-Phe-Leu-Val-Pro-Ala-Ala peptide: molecular structure (left) with polar region circled by a dashed line; ape of the amphipathic peptide. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2011, 13, 6914–6924 697.3228 5 719.4435 808.4813 0 600 700 800 1317.7437 850.3668 914.1219 900 967.1215 1008.0354 1000 1127.5109 1100 1212.1560 1263.7355 1200 1300 dimer 1356.6942 1445.2869 1400 1500 6915 m/z Peptides forming reversible « coacervates » Dimer mass at zero concentration obtained from Light scattering The octanol-water « buoyancy » of dimers The water-octanol « buoyancy » effect logP = log ( [peptide]octanol / [peptide]water ) -5 -5,5 -6 1,2 -6,5 octanol 1,0 water 0,9 ΔG w-->o (kJ/mol) 1,3 1,1 log P 2011 282 nm 600 Relative abundance kages between amino-acids, and it is difficult to design ly in the form of micelles.13 minus (carboxylic acid and head groups and bring a re. A way to bring hydroremity of the peptide and to side groups such as leucine phenylalanine (Phe), etc. part as the polar head group ntial complexant properties ll also be the only functional uence the C-ter is kept free o acids like alanines (Ala). he rest of the molecule by a nker. With a view to further ng the Ala2 group, the linker Gly) to avoid epimerization g the hydrophobic part, we etyl (non labile, bio-friendly m the linker to the N-ter is lky amino-acids, so that the with a small head group and eometry has been chosen to ganic solvents by potentially tes, like in the case of a well sulfosuccinate (AOT) in isoructures designed for a large the Hofmeister classification ration have been selected: d Ac-Phe-Leu-Val-Gly-Alane was decided to allow easy y = -0,0932x + 20,349 R² = 0,968 -7 -7,5 -8 -8,5 -9 0,8 -9,5 0,7 0 10 20 30 40 50 Peptide total concentration (mM) « hydrophibising » a peptide with temperature ? 60 -10 270 280 290 300 310 320 Temperature (K) Salting-in and salting-out as Hofmeister discovered in 1880 8 2N ! 52d 8m 8 p,w /dT p . w This relation shows the constra ε. σ lipid to the σ polymer solution inside the bag. During this pro519 It should be clear thattransition what wetemperature measure here istransition the des and cess, an optically clear monophasic domain may occur in the V(r)=4ε.[(σ/r)12 - (σ/r)6] Teflon cap excess entropy, that part of the entropy that contributes the transitioto temperature T p at which Sol-gel globule equilibrium : a liquid-gas equilibrium : coexistence of dilute andseal « gelled » phase reservoir, showing that the hemoglobin lyotropic liquid crystal hasthe left With O-ring where r is the distance between two particles, σ is size, and ε is the attractive en transition. theattractive coexistence In this case, waterphase or surfactant has Stainless to steelbyscrewchanges in the stress P p at transit where r is the distance between two particles, σ is the size, and ε is the energyregion. at condensed and a dilutedbephase. of repulsiveand van der~ SWaals The transition toLuciteosmotic-pressure language is immedia added We to theconsider reservoiraincombination order to recover the coexistence cover with samplmg 2S Serum cap a 8opening, a ! dT p 5 ~ V a 8 2V a ! dP p . rubber stopper, and positioning notches equilibrium +function globulesof the ratio contact. A dimensional analysis shows that ε is a simple effected by recalling that a volume water V w is the n plateau pressure. For example, at room the function of theofratio contact. A dimensional analysis shows that εtemperature, is a simple N2 above This is a kind of compensation betw Solutions r7 interactions, part of this equilibrium van der Waals contribution beingT500 counter-balanced by the adsorption concentration of Dextran was 2 N, inlet N with stopcock of water times the mola ber ~Pharmacia! of moles ~or molecules! w Polyethylene x = ρG / ρL work-induced contributions to the diff tubing 2661 wt. %. Therefore, the equilibrium plateau pressure is of water, v w , molecular! volume It can be rewritten to look like a Cla 5.660.1 x = ρion / on ρdensity Lucite carousel G the Lthe Semi-permeable determined to be 10 Pa.membrane of a chaotropic peptide. sample holder where ρG and ρL are respectively the density of the gas and of the condensed tion, V w 5as v waNreserThis new method, using the diphasic sample w or N w 5V w / v w . Concentrated dextran solution phase. This function can be obtainedAby fitting model the values from accurate voir, thatis the pressure after potential microphase dP p potential S a 8 2S of a water simple ofρaGcalculated Van derρrecognizes Waals fluid theosmotic Lennard-Jones (LJ) V(r)chemical described asdensity Changes d mthe are, con by where and are respectively the density of gas and the Hemoglobltn L w in the 5 . of the solution separation is fixed at the coexistence value of the pressure, dT V 2V 71, 72 p a a 8 dP in osmotic pressure by a WA to /, changes Magnetic stirrer simulations of the phase diagram : an intensive property independent of thenition, amountrelated of material V(r)=4ε.[(σ/r)12 - (σ/r)6]in the two lamellar phases @ L # and @ L # . These phases do iuc1teIn carousel our notation, a 8 refers to the con phase. This function can be obtained the ! 52 values calculated from ! a a8 a by d mfitting Invthe case of ! dP ~ energy/vol ~ vol/mol ε = kBT / f(X) w ~ energy/mol holder w dilute ~swollen! phase V a 8 2V a , the have a macroscopic area of contact S. From previous micro- Sample (top view) « release »e associated with condensation, is alw of water durring agg. 2.3764 23.8121 scopic where r –is0.115163X the distance two particles, is71,the size, andof εthe is the energy at observations, it is σknown orderattractive of Opening with f(X) = 1.31 – 0.301026X / (1-0.443917X ) between for 72that Ssoisthat sample tube prefer to think in terms of chem 2 phase 6 who simulations 100 of the diagram : m /g. The implicit assumption here is that the interfaa a8 Opening Why does it « reverse »? rive relevant N 2N 5for~ Vthe 2V 2 and X = (1-x) / (1+x). ~ a 8 ! dPClausius–Clapey p. cial energy g .S is negligible compared to theof osmotic work w ratio w ! d m p,w gas equilibration a 8 contact. A dimensional analysis shows that ε is a simple function the Gibbs–Duhem relation, of creating the two phases. g is the surface energy per area There should not be any confusion about the assignmen ε = kBT / f(X) In the Ch. same manner, the size is obtained from MS Prouty, AN. Schechter and VA Parsegian: (0) (b)Determination of the phase diagram of an Déjugnat et al.. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2011;13:6914–24. between the twoFigure lamellar phases. Since this g is difficult to 2sdT1 v d p2S A single sample of protein solution contained in dialysis ran i n bei d m i 50. x = ρG / ρL 1. (a) Test-tube osmometer. assembling protein (1985) and science (1992) S a osmomet,er. are,tubingalways, entropy S. Entropies S a 8 and equilibrated to a much larger volume of polymer solution of known osmotic pressure. (b) Carousel Up to 6 the entropie −1/ 3 measure, the inverse osmotic stress approach used here to σ = g(Y) ρ L separate sample solutions can be equilibrated to the 2.3764 same polymer osmotic pressure. 23.8121 Our measurements at constant phase and automatically associated with any parh measure the pressure of the plateau had the to be independently with f(X) = 1.31 – 0.301026X / (1-0.443917X – not 0.115163X ) arearetwo that d p[0. There component where ρ and ρ are respectively the density of the gas and the density of the condensed L checked. In order to do have cross-checked thisbuffer inlar Atcomponent. Because S about is an extensive quantity, with g(Y) = 0.314 + 0.477Y 1/3 + 0.2124Y − 0.01151Y 3/2G with to a concentration loo,6 greater than operating rangethis, of thewe Knauer instrument. these that the G–D relation the expected equilibrium value. Gelled samples were firstreduces to concentrations, the osmotic pressure of dextran is also Apparent Hamaker varies in water, NaCl and other salts ? verse osmotic pressure Winsor of microemulsions method using aclassification cumbersome but preit per molefrom ~ordialysis molecule! of DDAB cooled or oxygenated upon removal sacs in virtually independent of buffer used, and choose of temperature.to normalize and function X = (1-x) / (1+x). order to permit good accurate volume measurement before For speed of equilibration, thethe use of values lower molecular and Y = 1.31− kBT /ε . phase. This can be obtained by fitting calculated from cise extrapolation method. 2sdT2n dwere m wtransition 2n m DDAB osmotic pressure P p of(1wthe dilution. Solutions of sodium dithionite made DDABrdplateau weight dextran or of polyethylene giyeol would If give the the 1,50 up withdedegassed buffer and used within 10 min of advantage of lower concentrationsThis and viscosity for the b. The extrapolation method: method requires temperature, then the entropy S a 8 the of amo the preparation. same osmotic pressure; but “tighter” creases semipermeablewith With this approach we have calculated the apparent Hamaker constanttermination A = ε and theof72 interWe normalize entropy and Hemoglobin concentrations were measured by dilution membranes might distance be necessary,D * thusfor slowing down different volume the repeat simulations thesame phasemanner, diagram 71,the : size In of the isDextran obtained 1,45 a portion is in KCN buffer (Van Assendelft, 1970) and equilibration. solutions werefrom made up and less than S of the dilute L phas densed L a 8 ofphase mole ~or molecule! a absorbanceof atDDABr, a fractions pureby collapsed phase buffer L a 8 ofatthefixed measurement of cyanomethemoglobin weight using degassed same temperapeptide distance in the condensed phase for each case. Results are reported in Table in 3. thediluted 540 nm. The solubility of the stock solution for each run composition (including dithionite) as the hemoglobin P decreases with temperature, then creation of the p exponential 1,40 ture. A monotonic close a simple was reladetermined at the S5s/n appropriate DDABr temperature solution curve, against which theytowere to be dialyzed. Equal and byN w 5n w /n DDA neat,negative ε = k BT / f(X) −1/ 3 ultracentrifugation as described by Hofrichter et al. of permeant species was preset. Cona 8 from the dilute phase must involve an densed phase charge Then,of the coexisting periodicities σ = g(Y ) ρ L tion is obtained.concentrations centrations dextran two solutions were determined after (1976). are 1,35 This normalization gives final equilibration by measuring refractivecrease index, using in entropy. measured usinganaAbbe biphasic sample. The periodicity Refractometer. The refractive index increment. 2.3764 23.8121of the L a 8 (e) Lysozymr with f(X) = 1.31 – 0.301026X / (1-0.443917X – 0.115163X ) in each buffer system usedawas determined byshallcorreH2O phase, when it for is dextran in equilibrium with swollen Wephase use the convention that quantity 1,30 dthe mobtained m DDABr50 w 2d Egg-white lysozyme (22SdT2N x crystallized) w was measurements on carefully prepared and diluted samples. 1/3 3/2 NaCl When dithionite had been added to the solution, a from Worthington Biochemical Co., Freehold, 1\;J. sponds to a graphically extrapolated pressure of the plateau with g(Y) = 0.314 + 0.477Y + 0.2124Y − 0.01151Y competitive, correction was made in the measured refractive index. Measurements were or in 0.10 M-sodium acetate 1,25 LiCl ”S0.5a 8carried 2S aoutchloride, a!(pH a 84.70), and X = (1-x) / (1+x). buffer M-sodium conditions chosen as shown in Fig. 4. Winsor This procedure is time DS5DS consuming, besalt,and,peptide, I : solubilisation failure; « solute » in excess to maintain lysozyme in monomeric form and achieve NaNO3 hydration (d) Hemoglobin samples cause it requires determination of a full set of pressures for moderate solubility. The concentration of lysozyme 2d m DDABrin 5SdT1N . d 1,20 Winsor II : excessiswater: extraction w d m wthe the entropy change experienced going from solutions after equilibration was determined by Hemoglobin S was prepared from blood of individuals Y = 1.31− k T / ε and . monophasic samples. Within the final accuracy, measuring the absorbance of a portion at 280 nm. homozygous or heterozygous for HbS by ion-exchange In the same manner, the concentrated size Bis obtained from Winsor III : three phase phase situation phase.lamellar-phase equilibrium, t During chromatography on DEAE-Sephacel. HbAS usedto(athe condensed 1,15 typically 20% in pressure approximately 0.1blood in the logphase P mixture of Hba or and IV: HbS) optimisation was a lysate from Winosr withput separation ( ) Procedure of f DDABr are equal, obtained by exchange transfusion. Hemoglobin samples units on the graphs, the inverse osmoticbuffer pressure corresponds −1/ 3 were dialyzed into 0.15 M-phosphate (pH 7.4), and Osmometer assembly for deoxygenated hemoglobins Translation in phase diagram ? 1,10 With this approach we have calculated the apparent Hamaker constant A = ε and th σ = g(Y) ρ RESULTS was carried out in a “glove box” in aa nitrogen concentrated by vacuum filtration andIV. ultrafiltration. L330 a 250 260 270 280 290 300 310 320 340 350 to the value obtained from the extrapolation method. 8 by an atmosphere. Oxygen pressure was monitored For osmotic stress experiments, samples were diluted m 5 m DDABr DDABr 15 Temperature,(K) 8 !/~ Nw ~ S the2S ing equilibration, water is transferred to or from reservoir A simple model of a Van der Waals fluid is the Lennard-Jones V(r)=4(LJ)[(potential /r)12V(r) - (described /r)6]as DeoxyhemogEobin S Polymerization 90 Temperature (°C) 70 SOLID H2O NaCl LiCl NaNO3 50 30 SOLUTION 10 -10 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 Peptide concentration (mM) A/kT M) Wesolubilisation examine two • PA Winsor andbinary related didodecyldimethylammon 1/3 3/2 : Hydrotropy, Because this necessary equality3. of with g(Y) peptide = 0.314 +distance 0.477Y +in 0.2124Y − 0.01151Y the condensed phase for each case. Results are ofreported in Table III. COMPUTATION OF ENTROPY FROM THE emulsification processes ( 1948…) systems,I…XII DDABr and DDACl, differing only in Gibbs–D the cou can take a difference of the OSMOTIC STRESS AND WATER VOLUME CHANGE ion. These differences appeara clearly a in thea compara and Y = 1.31− kBT /ε . AT TRANSITION m DDABr dT1N w dofm wthe l phase diagrams, shown in2d Fig. 3 as5Sfunctions Ch. Déjugnat et al.. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2011;13:6914–24. 12 sol is readily obtained as a clear solution. This is possibly true in certain of Schulman's experiments with sodium oleate.B In all cases yet examined S, and S , are isotropic. In all cases yet examined S, and S, are isotropic while G shows birefringence of greater or less intensity. A diagrammatic representation of phases the passage Type I to Type I1 In reality: lyotropic plusfrom microphase system via the S, G and S, stages of a Type IV system is illustrated in separation stability Fig. 2 in which I? has the significance explained in a later section. - Type I S, (S,+ excess organic liquid) R < I S, +G G G (R= 4 I) + S, f - w/o small aggregets as a vdW fluid Basis of liquid-liquid extraction water<>oil<>water - S , Type I1 (S,+ excess aqueous liquid) R > I FIG.2. Lyotropic crystals: viscosity and birefringence S , , G, S2 Changes in Aqueous Amphiphile Solutions in Absence of 6. -In the Micro-phase above two examples the effect an amphiphile on equal volumes separation : lowofinterfacial tension…. of water (or aqueous salt solution) and organic liquid has been described, but the same sequence of changes can be distinguished over very wide Translation diagram n fact the whole?sequence (probably all) volume ratios. inI phase + + + S, +- ( S , G) += G + (G S,) --f S, -+ ( S , -4q) • PA Winsor : Hydrotropy, solubilisation and related has been emulsification observed in the absenceI…XII of any organic liquid when a 1 213yo processes ( 1948…) aqueous solution of a mixture of C,,-C,, sodium secondary alkyl sulphates (containing 3-5yo sodium sulphate) was converted t o a solution of cyclohexylammonium alkyl sulphates by gradual addition of cyclohexylammonium chloride. Also it has been found that the hydrophilic character Phasedecreases diagramm : generic (I) tetradecan -3, of the molecule apparently in the series sodium Text here Schulman, Trans. Faraday SOC.1946, QB, 165. . Phase diagramm : reality with some electrolyte present (II) Terahedron : oil Toil 2Φ 2Φ Text 3Φ 2Φ water/HNO3 14 Acid/ metal salt oil Toil Text • Th.Z et al: Recycling metals by controlled transfer of ionic species between complex fluids (2014) 1Φ . 2Φ extractant 1Φ water C. Bauer et al: Liq/liq metal extraction: Phase diagram topology resulting from molecular interactions between extractant, ion, oil and water (2012) 15 extractant C. Bauer et al: Li/liqmetal extraction: Phase diagram topology resulting from molecular interactions between extractant, ion, oil and water (2012) 16 Phase diagramm cut to show : liquid-liquid phase separation (III) Text here +A- H+A- (b) Allows determination of the effective step of attraction potential H+A- (c) 3φ 3φ o o o Scattering decomposed in P(q) and S(q) TExt. Toil Toil 2φ TExt. 2φ 1φ Ext. w Ext. w Ext. ! Erlinger, C: Attractive Interactions between Reverse Aggregates and Phase Separation in Concentrated Malonamide Extractant Solutions (1999) 17 ThZ et al. :Recycling metals by controlled transfer of ionic species 18 between complex fluids: en route to “ienaics” (2014) Assume incompressible globular aggregates measured and expected phase diagramm Origin of the difference: Hamaker and/or coalescence? Combining steric, depletion, dispersion for the determination of the effective step of attraction potential: [DMDBTDMA] (M) 1,6 Limite de 3ème phase expérimentale (dans le Dodécane) Limite de 3ème phase théorique Das Bild kann nicht angezeigt werden. Dieser Computer verfügt möglicherweise über zu wenig Arbeitsspeicher, um das Bild zu öffnen, oder das Bild ist Das Bild kann nicht beschädigt. Starten Sie den Computer angezeigt werden. neu, und öffnen Sie dann erneut die Datei. Dieserdas Computer Wenn weiterhin rote x angezeigt wird, verfügt müssen Sie das Bild möglicherweise möglicherweise über löschen und dann erneut einfügen. zu wenig Arbeitsspeicher, um das Bild zu öffnen, oder das Bild ist beschädigt. Starten Sie den Computer neu, und öffnen Sie 1,2 Das Bild kann nicht angezeigt werden. Dieser Computer verfügt möglicherweise über zu wenig Arbeitsspeicher, um das Bild zu öffnen, oder das Bild ist Das Bild kann nicht beschädigt. Starten Sie den Computer angezeigt werden. neu, und öffnen Sie dann erneut die Datei. Dieserdas Computer Wenn weiterhin rote x angezeigt wird, verfügt müssen Sie das Bild möglicherweise möglicherweise über löschen und dann erneut einfügen. zu wenig Arbeitsspeicher, um das Bild zu öffnen, oder das Bild ist beschädigt. Starten Sie den Computer neu, und öffnen Sie dann 2 phases 0,8 3 phases Rc Rsd δ" " fluctuation de 10 % du taux de collage 0,4 r 0 0 1 2 3 [HNO3]org / [DMDBTDMA] Usage of the « Baxter » model (1964) : valid when potential is less than 1/10 of 19 D ; gives analytic expressions for S(q) and phase stability • Polarisability variation ? (a)! ! ! (b)! ! 20 Reverse micelles and molecular dynamics What we have learnt : Without specific key-lock vdW fluid is a good guess for globular colloids when attraction is dominant Dimers of hexapeptides : « hydrophilicity » is an illdefined concept : « octanol-waries » varies by up to an order of magnitude when salt is added Water-poor microemulsions Alias « reverse » micelles More or less organized aggregates Interface difficult to Define consitently • Ph. Guilbaud et ThZ: Depletion of water-in-oil aggregates from poor solvents: transition from weak aggregates towards reverse micelles (2014) Small reverse micelles in the « Winsor II » regime : vdW attraction governed by content of polar cores and givern liquid-liquid phase separation when no coalesence happens. 21 22