PEWEHV1E

q_"Y5..
.. ~ Cr~ "'<f
~
:':i~ ~,-tj~R~p.3/2006
~.
~J:
t)~t
'"~;s.o
%
..
tll
170>19'/'\
~
f -II
<6"'1'
... If
0
O~.
f).
BPXOBHV10TCYAHA PEnY6nV1KA MAKEAOHV1JA,
COCTaBeH 0A
npeTceAaTenOT
Ha CYAOT AaHe V1n\l1eB-npeTceAaTen
Ha COBeTOT, CYA\I1\11Te:
Ar\l1M
M\I1cpTap\l1\11HeBeHa KP4KOBCKa-Man\l1HKOBCKa-~neHOB\I1, co AP)f(aBH\I10T COBeTH\I1K
EneHIo1 TaneB, OAnY~YBajK\I1 no 6apal-beTO Ha OCYAeH\I10TJOBaH BpaH\I1WKOBCK\I10A
6\11TOna, 3a BOHpeAHO y6na)f(YBal-be Ha Ka3HaTa \I13pe~eHa co npaBOC\I1nHa npecYAa
Ha OCHOBH\I10TCYA 6101Tona K.6p.22/2004
0A 1.7.2004 rOA\I1Ha, nOTBPAeHa co
npecYAa Ha Anena4\110H\I10T CYA 6\11TOna K)f(.6p.631 12004 0A 22.6.2005
roA\I1Ha,
nOAHeceHo npeKY 6paHIo1TenoT Bac\I1n rOpr\l1eB-aABoKaT 0A 6\11TOna, no npeTxoAHo
np\l16aBeH\I10T n\l1CMeHnpeAnor Ha JaBH\I10T 06BIo1H\11
Ten Ha Peny6n\l1Ka MaKeAoH\I1ja
KOB.M .6p.3/2006
0A 17.1.2006
roA\I1Ha, Ha CeAH\I14aTa 0AP)f(aHa Ha AeH 2.2.2006
rOA\I1Ha, cornaCHO ~neH 401 CTaB 6 0A 3aKoHoT 3a Kp\l1BIo1~HaTanOCTanKa, AOHece
PEWEHV1E
r~_.~"
6apal-beTO Ha OCYAeH\I10TJOBaH BpaH\I1WKOBCK\I10A 6\11TOna, 3a BOHpeAHO
y6na)f(YBal-be Ha Ka3HaTa, nOAHeceHO npeKY 6paH\I1TenOT Bac\I1n rOpr\l1eB-aABOKaT
0A 6\11TOna, CE YBA>KYBA.
npeCYAaTa Ha OCHOBH\I10TCYA 6101Tona K.6p.22/2004
oA 1.7.2004
npeCYAaTa Ha Anena4\110H\I10T CYA 6\11TOna K)f(.6p.631 12004 0A 22.6.2005
nPEV1HALJYBAAT BO AenOT Ha 0AnYKaTa 3a K83H8T8;
roAIo1Ha\11
roA\I1Ha, CE
OCYAeH~OT JOBaH BpaH\I1WKOBCK\I10A 6\11TOna 3a Kp\l1B\I1~HOTO
Aeno
"npeA\I13B\I1KYBal-be Ha4\110HanHa, paCHa \11BepCKa OMpa3a, pa3Aop \11HeTpnen\l1BOCT"
no ~neH 319 GoTaB1 0A Kp\l1B\I1~H\I10T3aKOH\I1K,3a Koe e ornaceH B\I1HOBeHco
npBocTeneHaTa
npecYAa, CE OCYAYBA Ha Ka3Ha 3aTBOp BOTpael-be 0A 8-0CYM
MeCe4\11, co npecMeTaHo
BpeMe nOM\I1HaTOBO np\l1TBOp 0A 11.1.2004
AO 30.1.2004
roA\I1Ha.
06pa3nO)f(eH\I1e
Co npecYAa Ha OCHOBH\I10TCYA6\11TOna K.6p.22/2004
0A 1.7.2004 roAIo1Ha
06BIo1HeT\I10TJOBaH BpaH\I1WKOBCK\I10A 6\11TOna e ornaceH B\I1HOBeH3a Kp\l1B\I1~HO
Aeno ''npeA1013B\I1KYBal-be Ha4\110HanHa, pacHa \11BepcKa oMpa3a, pa3Aop \11
HeTpnen\l1BOCT" no ~neH 319 CTaB 1 0A Kp\l1BIo1~HIo10T
3aKOH\I1K\11OCYAeH Ha Ka3Ha
3aTBOp BO Tpael-be 0A 1-eAHa roA\I1Ha \116-wecT Mece4\11, Ba Koja MYe npeCMeTaHO \11
BpeMeTO nOM\I1HaTOBO np\l1TBOp 0A 11.1.2004
AO 30.1.2004
roA\I1Ha.
.,.- - ~, ",
!L.
o :.
104':~,. penY6~:1-:
t}
:..
C:c'
11 ~.
YK.6p..3/2006
~~
~
0
Cl:
~
000.,., J'i.....
.~.;
'iA~.
Anena4~OH~OT cYA SO 6~TOna COnpecYAa K>K. ~or~~"t()
1422.6.2005
roA~Ha, >Kan6~Te Ha 06s~HeT~OT JosaH BpaH~WKosCK~ ~
ros~OT 6paH~Ten
Bac~n ropr~es-aAsOKaT
0146~Tona, r~ OA6~n KaKOHeOCHosaH~, co WTOnpeCYAaTa
Ha OCHOSH~OTCYA6~Tona K.6p.22/2004 0141.7.2004 rOA~Ha so 4enocT ja
nOTsPA~n.
OCYAeH~OTce Haora Ha ~3AP>KysaJ-be Ha Ka3HaTa 3aTsop so Ka3HeHOnonpasH~OT AOM"lI1AP~30s0" 01426.7.2005 roA~Ha. Ka3HaTa MY3aspwysa Ha
7.11 .2007 rOA~Ha, co np~3Ha,. np~Tsop 01419 AeHa.
no npasoc~nHOCTa Ha npeCYAaTa, oCYAeH~oT npeKY 6paH~TenOT Bac~n
ropr~es-aAsOKaT
0146~Tona, 140BpXOSH~OTCYAHa Peny6n~Ka MaKeAoH~ja
nOAHece 6apaJ-be 3a sOHpeAHo'y6na>KysaJ-b8 Ha Ka3HaTa~ so Koe HaseAysa AeKa
HaCTan~ne HOS~ OKonHOCT~KO~ce oY~rneAHO nOA06H~ Aa AOBeAaT 140n06nara
oCYAa. Hos~Te OKonHOCT~Ha KO~ce TeMen~ 6apaJ-beTO, ce 0AHeeysaaT Ha CMpTTa
Ha TaTKOTOHa OCYAeH~oTHa 31.1 0.2005 rOA~Ha, so nOTsPAa Ha WTOKOH6apaJ-beTO
e np~nO>KeH ~3s0A 014MaT~YHaTa KH~ra.Ha YMpeH~Te nOA 6p.953 3a onWT~Ha
6~Tona, TeWKaTa nC~X~YKa cocToj6aTa Ha MajKaTa Ha oCYAeH~oT npeA~3s~KaHa 014
CMpTTa Ha Hej3~H~oT conpyr, TaTKO Ha oCYAeH~oT ~ 3aTSapaJ-beTO Ha C~HOT.
BoeAHO, so 6apaJ-beTO e HaseAeHo AeKa HOsa OKonHOCTe ~ caMOTO0AHecysaJ-be ~
noseAeH~e Ha oCYAeH~oT, KOj~3AP>Kan Aen 014Ka3HaTa. npOMeHeTOTO noseAeH~e
so n03~T~SHa CM~cna cnopeA 04eHaTa Ha nOAHoc~TenoT Ha 6apaJ-beTO,
npeTcTasysa
san~AeH 3aKOHCK~OCHOS3a sOHpeAHo y6na>KysaJ-be Ha Ka3HaTa.
lI1CTOTaKa, so 6apaJ-beTO e HaseAeHo AeKa np~ 0AnyYysaJ-beTO CYAOTTpe6a Aa ~Ma
~ npeAs~A ~ npecYAaTa Ha BpXOSH~OTCYAHa Peny6n~Ka MaKeAoH~ja
Ksn.6p.191 /2005014 13.9.2005 roA~Ha, co Koja e nOTsPAeHa caMaTa Ka3Ha 3aTsop
no npecYAaTa K.6p.22/2004 so TpaeJ-be 0141-eAHa rOA~Ha ~ 6-wecT Mece4~, HO
cenaK 6apaJ-beTO AenYMHo e ysa>KeHO, Ha TOjHaY~H WTOSCYWHOCT
ce OTCTpaHeT~ ~
He ce COCTaseH Aen Ha 3aKOHCKOTO6~T~e Ha Kp~S~YHOTOAeno 014yneH 319 CTas 1
014Kp~S~YH~OT 3aKOH~K, Ase TpeT~H~ 014nps06~TH~Te AejcTs~ja HaseAeH~ KaKO
Ka3H~S~ so npecYAaTa. CnopeA 04eHaTa Ha nOAHoc~TenoT Ha 6apaJ-beTO,
npecYAaTa Ha BpXOSH~OTCYAHa Peny6n~Ka MaKeAoH~ja Ksn.6p.191/2005
KaKO
Hosa OKonHOCT,~CTOTaKa Aasa AosonHo OCHOS3a y6na>KysaJ-be Ha Ka3HaTa. Co
orneA Ha HaseAeHoTo, npeAnara 6apaJ-beTO 3a sOHpeAHo y6na>KysaJ-be Ha Ka3HaTa
Aa ce ysa>K~, na AOKonKYcYAoT ro ysa>K~ 6apaJ-beTO 3a sOHpeAHo npe~cn~TysaJ-be
Ha npasoc~nHaTa
npecYAa Kc.6p.21 0/2005014 9.9.2005 rOA~Ha, Ha TOjHaY~H WTOKe
ce YTSPA~ KaKOHeOCHosaHO OTnos~KysaJ-beTO Ha ycnosHaTa oCYAa no
K.6p.447/2003 Aa OCTaHe caMO YTsPAeHaTa Ka3Ha 3aTsop so npecYAaTa
K.6p.22/2004 0141-eAHa roA~Ha ~ 6-wecT Mece4~ ~ osaa Ka3Ha Aa 6~Ae sOHpeAHo
y6na>KeHa co ycnosysaJ-be Ha ~CTaTa. AOKonKYnaK, 6apaJ-beTO 3a sOHpeAHo
npe~cn~TysaJ-be Ha npasoc~nHaTa npecYAa Kc.6p.21 0/2005 6~Ae oA6~eHo ~ OCTaHe
YTsPAeHa eA~HcTseHaTa Ka3Ha 3aTsop so TpaeJ-be 0142-Ase roA~H~ ~ 4-YeT~p~
Mece4~, osaa eA~HcTseHa Ka3Ha 6~Ae sOHpeAHo y6na>KeHa no csojaTa B~C~Ha co
YTsPAysaJ-be Ha nOMana Ka3Ha 3aTsop ~n~ Aa 6~Ae ycnoseHa.
JasH~OT 06s~H~Ten Ha Peny6n~Ka MaKeAoH~ja nocTanysajK~ so paMK~Te Ha
osnacTysaJ-baTa cOAp>KaH~so yneH 401 CTas 5 0143aKoHoT 3a Kp~S~YHaTa
nOCTanKa, 140osoj cYAAocTas~ n~CMeH npeAnor KOB.M.6p.3/2006 01417.1.2006
3
roAVlHa, BO KOj npeAllara 6apal-beTO Ha OCYAeHVlOTJOBaH
OA6V1eKaKO HeOCHOBaHO.
B
6apal-beTO e OCHOBaHO.
Co npecYAa Ha OCHOBHVlOTCYA 6V1TOlla Kc.6p.21 0/2005 0A 9.9.2005 roAVlHa
nOTBPAeHa co npecYAa Ha Anella4V10HVlOT CYA 6V1TOlla Kc.6p.88/2005
0A 31.1 0.2005
roAVlHa, OTnOBVlKaHa e YClloBHaTa oCYAa Vl3peLJeHa co npaBocVlllHa npecYAa Ha
OCHOBHVlOTCYA 6V1TOlla K.6p.447/2003
0A 31.1 0.2003 rOAVlHa, npoTVlB oCYAeHVloT
JOBaH BpaHVlwKoBCKVI 0A 6V1Tolla 3a KpVlBVlLJHO
Aello "CaMoBllacTVle" no LJlleH 392
CTaB2 0A KpVlBVlLJHVlOT
3aKOHVlK,comaCHO LJlleH52 CTaB 2 0A VlCTVlQT
3aKOH.
d
ComacHo LJlleH 51 CTaB 3 0A KpVlBVI~H'VlOT3aKOHVlK, Ha 06BVlHeTVlOTJOBaH
BpaHVlWKOBCKVI3a.KpVlBVlLJHOTO
AellO "CaMOBllaCTVle" no LJlleH 392 CTaB 2 0A
KpVlBVlLJHVlOT
3aKOHVlK no npaBocVlllHaTa npecYAa K.6p.447/2003
oA 31.1 0.2003
roAVlHa, YTBPAeHa MY e Ka3Ha 3aTBOp BOTpael-be 0A 1-eAHa rOAVlHa, 3a KpVlBVlLJHOTO
Aello "npeAVl3BVlKYBal-be Ha4V1oHallHa, pacHa VIBepcKa oMpa3a, pa3Aop VI
HeTpnellVlBocT" no LJlleH 319 CTaB 1 0A KpVlBVlLJHVlOT
3aKOHVlK no npaBocVlllHa
npecYAa K.6p.22/2004 0A 1.7.2004 rOAVlHa, YTBPAeHa MY e Ka3Ha 3aTBOp BOTpael-be
0A 1-eAHa rOAVlHa Vl6-weCT Mece4V1, na co npVlMeHa Ha LJlleH 44 Vl3peLJeHa MY e
eAVlHCTBeHa Ka3Ha 3aTBOp BOTpael-be OA 2-ABe rOAVlHVIVl4-LJeTVlpVlMece4V1.
BpXOBHVlOTCYA Ha Peny6llVlKa MaKeAoHVlja co npecYAa KBn.6p.3/2006 0A
2.2.2006 rOAVlHa 6apal-beTO 3a BOHpeAHo npeVlcnVlTYBal-be Ha npaBOCVlllHaTa
npecYAa Ha OCYAeHVlOTJOBaH BpaHVlWKOBCKVInOAHeceHO 0A HeroBVloT 6paHVlTell
BaCVlll rOpfVleB-aABOKaT OA 6V1TOlla, npOTVlB HaBeAeHVlTe npecYAVI ro YBa)!(VI VI
npeCYAVlTe Ha OCHOBHVlOTCYA 6V1Tolla Kc.6p.21 0/2005 0A 9.9.2005 roAVlHa VI
Anella4V1oHVloT cYA 6V1T0J.1aKc)!(.6p.88/2005
0A 31.1 0.2005 roAVlHa rVl npeVlHaLJVI,
TaKa WTO ro OA6V1npeAlloroT Ha OCHOBHOTOjaBHo 06BVlHVlTellCTBO 0A 6V1Tolla 3a
OTnOBVlKYBal-be Ha YCllOBHaTa oCYAa Ha OCYA6HVlOTJOBaH BpaHVlWKOBCKVI.
Bo BaKBaTa cocToj6a, BpXOBHVlOTCYA YTBPAVIAeKa 6apal-beTO 3a BOHpeAHO
y6lla)!(YBal-be Ha Ka3HaTa ce 0AHeCYBa caMO Ha Ka3HaTa YTBPAeHa co npecYAa
K.6p.22/2004
0A 1.7.2004 rOAVlHa Ha OCHOBHVlOTCYA 6V1Tolla, nOTBPAeHa co
npecYAa Ha Anella4V10HVlOT CYA 6V1TOlla K)!(.6p.631/2004
0A 22.6.2005 rOAVlHa BO
Tpael-be 0A 1-eAHa rOAVlHa VI6-wecT Mece4V1 3aTBop.
ComaCHO LJlleH 399 0A 3aKoHoT 3a KpVlBVlLJHaT~nOCTanKa, y6lla)!(YBal-be Ha
npaBOCVlllHO Vl3peLJeHaTa Ka3Ha e A03BOlleHO .Kora no npaBOCVlllHOCTa Ha npeCYAaTa
Ke ce jaBaT OKOllHOCTVIWTO rVl HeMallO Kora ce Vl3peKYBalla npecYAaTa VlllVlCYAOT3a
HVlBHe 3Haell VlaKOnOCToelle, a TVle OLJVlmeAHO6V1AOBelle AO n06nara oCYAa.
BpXOBHVlOTCYA Ha Peny6llVlKa
OKonHOCT BO CMVlcna Ha LJlleH
MaKeAoHVlja 04eHVI AeKa 3HaLJel-be Ha HOBa
399 0A 3Kn, Tpe6a Aa A06V1enpeCYAaTa Ha
4
BYK.6p.3/2006
BpXOBHIt10T CY{J.Ha Peny6nlt1Ka MaKe{J.OHlt1ja KBn.6p.191 /2005 0{J.13.9.2005
ro{J.It1Ha,
co Koja {J.en 0{J.{J.ejcTBlt1jaTa cO{J.p)f(aHIt1BO Onlt1COTHa KpIt1BW-IHOTO
{J.eno 3a Koe 61t1n
OCY{J.eHO{J.nOHIt1CKIt1TeCY{J.OBIt1,
BpXOBHIt10T CY{J.Ha Peny6nlt1Ka MaKe{J.OHlt1ja rlt1
OTCTpaHlt11t1YTBP{J.1t1
{J.eKa He ce COCTaBeH {J.en Ha 3aKOHCKOTO 61t1TIt1eHa KpIt1BW-IHOTO
{J.eno o{J.l1neH 319 CTaB 1 0{J.KpIt1BIt1l1HIt10T
3aKOHIt1K, a KOIt1co Clt1rypHocT 61t1Bnlt1jaene
Ha BIt1CIt1HaTaHa Ka3HaTa, {J.OKonKY61t1ne Ha It1CTHal1It1HTpeTlt1paHIt1 BO nOHIt1CKIt1Te
nOCTanKIt1.
Bo OBaa CMIt1Cna, BpXOBHIt10TCY{J.Ha Peny6nlt1Ka MaKe{J.OHlt1ja It1CTaKHa BO Taa
npecY{J.a {J.eKa cnope{J. KpIt1BIt1l1HIt10T
3aKOHIt1K, no TOj npaBeH neK It1BO Taa cpa3a Ha
nOCTanKaTa l;ieMa OBnaCTYBa/-be {J.aja npelt1Cnlt1TYBa BIt1CIt1HaTaHa Ka3HaTa, OCBeH
Hej31t1HaTa 3aKOHIt1TOCTIt1{J.eKa Taa MO)f(e {J.a 61t1{J.enpelt1Cnlt1TaHa no BOHpe{J.HOnpaBHO
cpe{J.CTBO 3a y6na_)f(YBa/-be ~a ~a3HaTa.
Cera,
BO OBaa nOCTanKa nOCTanYBajKIt1 no BaKBO BOHpe{J.HOnpaBHO cpe{J.CTBO,
BOCMIt1CnaHa l1neH 401 CTaB 6 0{J.3Kn, "BPXOBHIt10T
CY{J.
Ha Peny6nlt1Ka MaKe{J.OHlt1ja
YTBP{J.1t1
{J.eKa 1t13pel1eHaTa Ka3Ha 3aTBOp O{J.1-e{J.Ha ro{J.It1HaIt16-weCT Mece41t1 e
.
npeBIt1COKa, lt1M8.jKIt1
rlt1npe{J.BIt1{J.OKOnHOCTIt1Te Ha HaManeH~1Te {J.ejcTBlt1jaO{J.Onlt1COT
Ha KpIt1BIt1l1HOTO
{J.eno KaKO HGBIt1OKOnHOCTIt1,KaKO It1HOBaTa OKonHOCT Koja
HaCTaHana no 1t13peKYBa/-beTO Ha Ka3HaTa, a Taa e CMpTTa Ha TaTKOTO Ha OCY{J.eHIt10T.
BpXOBHIt10TCY{J.Ha Peny6nlt1Ka MaKe{J.OHlt1ja BO CMIt1CnaHa l1neH 32 It139 0{J.
KpIt1BIt1l1HIt10T
3aKOHIt1K,04eHIt1 {J.eKa HOBIt1TeOKOnHOCTIt1ce Clt1rypHa OCHOBa 3a 04eHKa
{J.eKa Ka3HaTa 0{J.8-0CYM Mece41t1 3aTBop, Ke ja nOCTlt1rHe 4enTa Ha Ka3HYBa/-beTO It1
{J.eKa y6na)f(YBa/-beTO Ha Ka3HaTa e BO paMK~ne Ha CTeneHOT Ha KpIt1BIt1l1HaTa
O{J.roBOpHOCT, nOBpe{J.aTa Ha 3aWTIt1TeHOTO {J.06po It1{J.eKa OBaa Ka3Ha KpajHo BO
BKynHoTo {J.ejcTBo Ke Bnlt1jae Ha nlt1l1HOCTa Ha CTOplt1TenOT It1nOTpe61t1Te O{J.HerOBa
pec041t1
jan
1t13a41t1ja.
Co orne{J. Ha 06pa3nO)f(eHOTO,
ce o{J.nYl11t1KaKO BO 1t13peKaTa Ha peWeHlt1eTO.
PeweHO BO BpXOBHIt10TCY{J.Ha Peny6m.iKa
rO{J.V1Hano{J. BYK.6p.3/2006.
MaKe{J.OHlt1ja Ha {J.eH2.2.2006
Ha CY{J.OT-COBeTOT
nlt1eB C.p.
3a TOl1HOCTa Ha OTnpaBOKOT TBp{J.lt1:
n,Q./
.I
I
i
r
.
---L